Good Saturday on this Labor Day weekend, Threaders, Threadheads, and all in between. Coffee was good.
Waking up to bad news is not what I wished for, especially having slept in on a lazy Saturday. There was a lot on my mind already. I had planned an open letter to the president of the University of Maryland, reproducing my email to him. But the world keeps on turning…
By now you probably heard that the president of the University of Maryland, Darryl Pines, approved the Students for Justice in Palestine “celebration” of October 7. They didn’t call it exactly that but what else is there to celebrate by a Hamas and Iranian sponsored organization on that date? It’s pretty clear to me that had the same SJP requested permission for a “celebration of 9/11” on campus on September 11 they would have been denied. But I guess it’s “just the Jews” so it’s okay.
If you haven’t signed the protest letter to Univ. of Maryland about this please do so using this link. (Click here.)
I know this will break my string but do try to go on reading past 3 of 16 by returning here and moving down the thread. Hope you make it. So…
There’s that. And the real bad news came to me this morning as @lisaaronowatelier posted about the IDF discovery of an undetermined number of hostage bodies in Gaza. Nearly a year since October 7, just as the anti-Israel simps prepare to “celebrate” the occasion, so many families still live in despair and so many others live with the confirmation of a loss that can never be made whole. We’re bracing for just how bad these news are…
At the same time, the army being accused of genocide is pausing its operations in Gaza so that tens of thousands of children can be given the first dose of a Polio vaccine. For those still accusing the IDF of inhumane behavior make it make sense. Responding to a truly genocidal attack by a terrorist organization that controls a small enclave where there’s no telling who is who among a population that mostly supports it and actively participated in the same attack is tragic.
I wrote extensively about this war, how hard it is to conduct urban warfare in such an environment and how this isn’t your “traditional” hostage situation where you can deal with it using law enforcement or special forces, etc. It’s kind of exhausting going over this again and again so I will leave it at that and if you are so inclined you can search my past threads for it. What I want to address today is how the strategy of war has been wrong from the start and is causing so much pain.
Israel has been at war since her independence in 1948. Pain is no stranger to Israelis. The Arabs in the region are no stranger to it either. When we talk about pain, as Jon Polin made us remember, there are no winners. When we talk of pain we don’t talk of soldiers who are trained for combat and are expected to endure its consequences. We talk about the innocent. For me it’s always been about families. Those who endure the pain war causes by extension. Those without guilt.
I know most Palestinian Arabs have been radicalized since they were children. I know that for that reason most of them, in Gaza and the West Bank, support Hamas and wish for the destruction of Israel. I also know the Hamas propaganda machine is good at making shit up but when they hide among civilians and a bomb gets them that doesn’t make me feel any better about the children caught in it. Not at all. Which brings me to Netanyahu.
From day one it was very clear the hostages were an afterthought in the response strategy laid out by Netanyahu’s government where a majority of right wing religious Zionists rule. As the war progressed that became even more clear. The IDF is not the extension of those policies many think it is. Sure, like in any army, there are elements who commit war crimes - look no further than our own military - but those are a small group.
To prove it, even in a radical Jewish government, the disagreement between the Defense minister, Yoav Gallant, and the rest of the Cabinet has always been public and just reached new heights. The most recent face off between him and Bibi is about the hostages again. It seems like the main obstacle to reach a consensus on the return of the hostages and the adjacent ceasefire is now the occupation of the South Gaza area known as the Philadelphi Corridor, the 14 Km borderline with Egypt.
We all know it’s important to keep Hamas from being resupplied using that area but we also know that since the IDF took control of it a large number of tunnels between Gaza and Egypt were destroyed and that capability severely affected. Everyone understands that a ceasefire will enable Hamas to regroup and certainly cause harm to Israel but that should have NEVER been the priority with hostages in play. Netanyahu has been denying ceasefires for personal reasons.
No one, except the people who wish for the destruction of Israel, denies her right to self defense and whenever Hamas breaks a truth or ceasefire there will be consequences. Withdrawal from a fucking 9 mile strip means nothing compared to getting the hostages back. If shit happens after that the IDF will get it again. It’s not fucking rocket science! Of course it’s hard to let go of ground gained with blood. Of course it will take more sacrifices to get it back if needed.
That’s why soldiers die. To prevent civilians from dying. This is not about saving the IDF more casualties, as painful as that is; it’s about saving civilian lives. From the start that has been a problem for the Israeli strategy because a less aggressive intervention would have caused more IDF casualties. We all know this but what most don’t know is the IDF is fine with it and every day suffer casualties trying to save innocent lives, Jewish AND Muslim lives, Israeli AND Palestinian.
Gallant is telling Netanyahu to take the deal by accepting to withdraw from the fucking corridor. Get the hostages home! But Bibi says no. He just wants the war to go on. This is real. The hostage families are calling for major demonstrations in Israel to demand Netanyahu accepts the deal in the wake of today’s tragic news. Some of those families are about to be told their loved ones are coming home dead. Their suffering is unimaginable. Yet they fight.
While millions of Israelis rise against this inhumane strategy, and the IDF stands ready to sacrifice anything to save lives, here at home some pretend this isn’t happening and couldn’t care less how many more people die in this war as long as it ends with all Jews thrown into the Mediterranean. These people are as despicable as Netanyahu and are getting ready to celebrate the death of 1200 Jews and glorify rape, torture and murder as legitimate resistance on 10/7/24.
That’s not all they will be celebrating. They will also celebrate thousands of Palestinian deaths, glorifying them while ordering vegetarian pizzas. They are the scum of the scum in this death cult, because, while part of it, they are sure their lives are not threatened, their faces hidden by keffiyehs they don’t even know the meaning of. They’re deplorable. I am waiting for news. My thoughts are with the hostages and their families tonight. Shalom Aleichem.
Release the hostages.