A couple of weeks away from Election Day, in spite of the clear and present danger posed by the current regime, the opposition to it is still haunted by some of its members embrace of antisemitism - explicit or implicit; aware or mislead. It’s the uncommitted ghost of elections past coming back around, and it’s a serious threat to an otherwise slam dunk election.
Being a Zionist progressive (in the true sense of progress, opposed to conservative stagnation), and an agnostic gentile, I find reasons to be concerned - and frustrated - not only on the far left encroached in the Democratic Party but also in relatively small, but very vocal, sectors of the Jewish community that align with the fascist regime. My “How can any Jew vote for a Nazi?” meme comes to mind. How, indeed.
In an effort to move voters away from the Democrats, these right wing voices make the same exacerbating argument the far left uses against Israel: in both cases, the fact that some are wrong makes the group they belong to insufferable; the DSA infiltration of the Democratic Party makes all Democrats rabid antisemites and the Kahanist infiltration of the Israeli government makes all Israelis (and by extension all Jews) staunch fascists. Populism at its finest.
As a defender of Democracy AND Israel, and once more as a Zionist, my main concern is on the left side of the equation, but this duality of disinformation efforts brings me to how I react to it when faced with antisemitism coming from my Democratic friends. If you are a liberal Zionist, you know what I am talking about. Politics is always on the table these days, when you are aware of what’s going on, and conversations with also aware friends are frequent.
The disappointment, the rage, the deep seeded anger, the unlikely hope, the need for real change, all these things are shared in that awareness and make such conversations happen in a very like minded setting. Until someone says: “I checked Sherrod Brown and he is not taking money from AIPAC.” Excuse me? As like minded as I am, I am NOT like that. My immediate reaction to this particular situation (yes, it did happen) was “I don’t give a fuck if he gets AIPAC money.”
I do give a fuck if ANY politician gets money from ANY PAC, but that’s the current nature of the game, with Citizens United active and zero election reform that removes all money from electoral campaigns. This particular friend is in the misguided category, not extreme at all; they are in fact surprised by how much more extreme my views are than theirs, in some cases, and this is the only contentious point in an otherwise excellent relationship. But it’s a point I never let slide.
I absolutely agree that when it comes to antisemitism (and fascism) there are those who can’t be trusted to have honest conversations. They are chaos agents or useful idiots and lack the willingness or the intellect to discuss politics. This is where I imagine how some of my Jewish thriends, who never voted Republican in their lives, must feel when during an otherwise like minded conversation about Israel someone comes out and praises Itamar Ben-Gvir. Or Trump.
This to say that, despite these serious kinds of shortcomings, some friendships can be maintained and conversations must continue. We’re not all the same, and none of us are perfect. I am convinced that the majority of those on the wrong side of history don’t know enough history to even pick a side. They just go along. It’s the old sitting at a table with a Nazi allegory; if you find 10 people sitting at a table with a Nazi, you got 11 Nazis at a table.
Only if one of those 10 people is your friend, or relative, and you walk past the table without stopping and asking them what the fuck do they think they’re doing, you become a Nazi enabler. It is your responsibility to speak up and fight against injustice. Do not look away, change subject, or ignore it. Whether we’re talking about a fellow Democrat or a fellow Jew expressing support for anti democratic values under false pretenses, never give it a pass because of who they are.
Chances are reason will prevail, and you will be able to inform and help them see how wrong they are. And if that doesn’t happen, so be it. Friendships and family ties will be broken by intolerance; nothing one can do about extreme prejudice, but you must never give up the fight. It’s hard and frustrating, but no one said it would be easy. And remember who we are fighting against on the big stage, so we can defeat it.
If we do not defeat this fascist regime in November, even with some shady characters on the Democratic side of the ballot, these difficult conversations we have will not be possible anymore. So keep having them while you can; stand up for what’s right, and never ever give an inch to antisemitism or fascism. The world can only change for the better with room to maneuver. Let’s make room first, and then we can change it.
Drink coffee. Vote wisely. Fuck fascism.